A Beginner’s Guide to Buying Jewelry Online

woman buying jewelry online on her tablet holding a credit card

Shopping for jewelry online offers convenience and the opportunity to discover unique pieces you might not find in local stores. However, the sheer number of online jewelry stores and artisan designers can make the experience feel overwhelming. Choosing the perfect piece while ensuring its high quality requires a thoughtful approach. 

From finding trusted sellers to evaluating materials and selecting the right fit and style, this online jewelry buying guide will walk you through everything you need to know about how to buy jewelry online.

Where to Buy Jewelry Online

Knowing where to shop is the first step in learning how to buy jewelry online. Start by researching reputable online jewelry stores that specialize in the materials or styles you love. For example, some stores focus on sterling silver or gemstone jewelry, creating timeless designs that stand out.

When browsing smaller handmade jewelry designer websites, look for detailed product descriptions and clear policies, including their refund policy. Reviews can be helpful to evaluate individual pieces and the customer experiences, but if a site doesn’t include reviews don’t let that deter you from exploring newer businesses. Instead, pay attention to the professionalism of the site, including clear photos and thorough descriptions of the jewelry’s materials, size, and craftsmanship. 

If the site has a media section, check for news features to learn more about the business and its legitimacy.

Evaluating Materials & Jewelry Quality

woman wearing layered sterling silver jewelry including a triple broken silver necklace and three gemstone necklaces

Understanding materials is key to ensuring you purchase high-quality jewelry pieces. One of the biggest concerns when buying jewelry online is being unsure about the quality. For metals, sterling silver jewelry is durable and versatile while also safe for most people with skin sensitivities. Steel jewelry is another excellent choice for its ability to make lightweight and strong pieces, such as this Long Chain Link Necklace.

For gemstone jewelry, read descriptions carefully to verify jewelry quality and that authentic materials are used. Look for thorough descriptions and terms such as “natural” to evaluate authenticity. High-quality jewelry typically includes specifics about the materials, such as the carat weight of gemstones or specific qualifiers for gold or silver finishes, such as “24k gold” or “sterling silver”.

Take time to look at images to see details about craftsmanship, such as soldered closures and secure settings. These elements can give you confidence in the durability of your purchase.

Finding the Right Size and Fit

Proper sizing is essential when buying jewelry online. For rings, if you’re unsure of your size, measure your finger and use an online sizing chart. If you’re shopping for bracelets or necklaces, pay close attention to the length measurements provided. You can use a string and tape measure on yourself or measure a piece of jewelry you own to help determine how a piece will fit on. Earrings are always a safe choice when you don’t know the right size for a gift. Learn more tips on choosing the best size and length of jewelry when shopping online.

Many artisan jewelers offer adjustable designs, which are perfect for gifting or ensuring a versatile fit. If you’re unsure, check the product details for sizes or contact the seller for guidance. Most jewelry designers are happy to help guide you on finding the best piece of jewelry for you or for someone else if buying for a gift.

Choosing Colors and Style

urved corner steel and silver pendant necklace statement jewelry piece

When selecting jewelry, you’ll want to consider both color and style. For metals, sterling silver’s cool tone complements most gemstones and matches many skin tones. If you’re choosing a piece of jewelry with gemstones, think about how the color will pair with your wardrobe or the recipient’s preferences.

Balance your choices between everyday designs and statement pieces like this Curved Corner Steel & Silver Necklace. Sleek, minimalist styles in fine silver or steel are great for daily wear, while bold, gemstone-accented designs make striking additions for special occasions. Our Mini Broken Silver Ring is a perfect everyday piece.

Supporting Small Jewelry Businesses

Silver mod drop earrings available to buy online at Zink Metals

One of the best parts of buying jewelry online is the opportunity to support small businesses. Many jewelry artists focus on creating one-of-a-kind designs with a personal touch, making your purchase truly unique. A distinctive piece of jewelry makes an unparalleled gift. You may even discover that some designers offer custom jewelry services that big box retailers can’t match.

Shopping small also often means supporting detailed craftsmanship. Many artisans prioritize quality over quantity, ensuring each piece is handcrafted with care. This can be an advantage over mass produced jewelry that often lacks durability.

Building a connection with the designer or becoming a repeat buyer can add an extra layer of satisfaction to your purchase — you’re not just buying jewelry; you’re investing in a story. You can follow them on social media or sign up for their newsletter to stay updated on local events where they’ll be, new product alerts, and follow the business’ journey.

Shop Online Jewelry Styles

Shopping for jewelry online doesn’t have to be intimidating. By focusing on reputable sellers, understanding materials, and choosing pieces that match your style and fit, you can confidently navigate the process and learn how to buy jewelry online with confidence. Whether you’re drawn to timeless pieces or bold statement designs, we hope this online jewelry buying guide can help you make an informed and satisfying purchase.

Shop Zink Metals Jewelry